Standards:
-LAFS.6.L.1.2: Conventions
-LAFS.K12.R.3.8: Arguments and claims
-LAFS.4.L.1.F: Complete sentence structure
Essential Question
-How do you develop and apply logic and reasoning in the art of persuasion?
Agenda
1. Go over all assignments from last class; answer all questions; and give time to work
A Modest Proposal: continued
a. Read and discuss 608, 609
b. Students must be able to identify the four sections of the essay
- Problem
- Solution/proposal
- Support
- Others arguments with a defense against them
c. Assign all margin and end questions
B. Additional assignments for "A Modest Proposal"
a. Seeing beneath the writing: Create a description of what the Irish people's life must have been like at that time. Tie the description to page and line number.
b. Give examples of irony and exaggeration. Tie to page and line numbers.
c. Give examples of what he said versus what he meant. Tie to page and line numbers.
C. Group/team challenge
a. Choose any arguable topic
b. Using listing or informal writing techniques, Develop the 4 stages of the problem/solution structure used in the "Modest Proposal"
1. Outline and completely identify the problem
2. Give the proposal/solution to the problem
3. Provide/list the support for your solution
4. Reveal the opposing arguments to your solution and defend against them.
2. Using Evidence and Logic assignment
a. Go over Using Evidence and Logic handout, pointing out the importance of avoiding lazy thinking
b. Read "Political Language" with some explanation
c. Read "Speech by Senator Yakalot" with some explanation
d. Allow students to select which handout they want to use as a challenge to studying the "Using Evidence and Logic.
e. The logic test will be in one week
f. Assignment: students are to identify the fallacies from the Evidence handout on the practice handout they have selected. They only need to write the number of the fallacy by the fallacy in the practice handout.